What are the disadvantages of the AFAS Mentorship scheme?

An article about the downsides of your own service. Not the smartest marketing move, you might think.

We’re going ahead with it anyway. You’re bound to come across these drawbacks eventually, and you’d rather hear about them from us now than in three months’ time during a review. Here they are, laid bare.

Let’s be honest: most of the downsides are simply our strengths, turned on their head. The set routine, the method, the focus on innovation. For most organisations, that is precisely why they choose us. For a smaller number, these are genuine concerns.

On an hourly basis, it works out more expensive than hiring a freelancer

We charge €140 per hour for everyone on your team. A freelance consultant specialising in AFAS often charges less than that. According to Freelancer.nl, rates in 2026 will average between €70 and €120 per hour.

On the other hand, our rates include travel time, preparation and any questions you may have in between. But if you look purely at the hourly rate, we aren’t the cheapest option.

See also: How much does AFAS Mentoring cost?

You’re stuck in a fixed routine

Mentoring involves a fixed day each week. That is precisely its strength, because something happens every week. But it is also a limitation.

Are you looking for someone who’ll only ring you when there’s a crisis? If so, this isn’t the right fit. We don’t work on an on-call basis. Even during a quiet week, your mentor will be working on the agreed actions. Nothing happens only in weeks when we’ve deliberately chosen not to work together, such as during your holiday. You won’t be charged for those weeks either.

And it does require a bit of effort from you. You need to be willing to work on it together every week. Anyone who can’t or won’t do that won’t get much out of it.

It takes up your staff’s time

As well as the cost of our invoice, mentoring also takes up your own team’s time. People sometimes forget that.

How much? If we’re mainly taking over your work, it’ll cost you about 1 to 2 hours for every 8 hours we work. If we train your own AFAS administrator, it’s more like 8 to 16 hours a week. That’s time that can’t be spent on anything else, so be sure to factor it into your budget.

It might not be worth it for a small organisation

Mentoring is most effective in organisations with robust processes and a large number of staff. The greater the volume, the greater the benefits. For a small organisation, the investment may not pay off.

There is one exception: a small organisation that wants to adopt a ‘digital first’ approach, with as much as possible automated. In that case, it can actually be worthwhile.

Half a day is actually not long enough

Half a day a week is possible, but we wouldn’t recommend it. Four hours isn’t long enough to actually finish anything.

That does mean, however, that the actual commitment is one day a week. That works out at around €1,260 a week, or just over €5,000 a month. For a smaller organisation, that’s a significant investment. If that doesn’t work, you can start with half a day, with the limitations that entails. Or perhaps mentoring isn’t the right step just yet.

It’s no small task

Are you looking for a project with a clear start and end? If so, mentoring might not be what you’re looking for.

Most clients stick with us for one day a week. Not because they’re tied in – you can cancel at any time – but because the nature of the work changes: from problem-solving to innovation. That’s great if you want to keep developing AFAS. If you expect it to be finished after six months, you’ll be in for a disappointment.

A lot depends on whether you get on with your mentor

You’ll be working closely with your mentor every week. That’s valuable, but it also means that the match is important. A mentor may be highly knowledgeable, yet still not be the right fit for your team.

If things aren’t working out, please discuss it with your project leader. They’ll first see if things can be improved, and if that isn’t possible, you’ll be assigned a different permanent mentor. But every change takes time. A new mentor has to get to know your environment all over again, and that’s precisely why we work with permanent mentors.

When is it better to choose something else?

A few situations where you’d be better off choosing something else.

Do you have a one-off query or a small job? In that case, you’re better off going directly to AFAS or using a freelancer. Are you mainly looking for the lowest hourly rate? Even then, a freelancer is cheaper. Do you only want help in a crisis? Then our fixed schedule won’t suit you. And if you only need a few hours a month on a regular basis, you’ll fall below our minimum requirement of half a day a week.

See also: Mentor, consultant, freelancer or in-house staff member: which one suits you best?

Where we went wrong

At the start, we worked without project managers. We built great things, but realised that wasn’t enough. Whatever you build has to be properly integrated into the organisation and actually put to use. You have to stick to what you’ve agreed. And if new requirements keep cropping up along the way, you lose sight of the overarching theme.

That is why we have introduced a project manager: someone who sets and monitors the parameters. And that is also why the process mentor role was created. Otherwise, we tend to dive straight into the content without considering what will really help your organisation move forward.

Why we’re writing this down

Because you’re bound to come across these drawbacks anyway. And because a partnership that starts with realistic expectations runs a lot more smoothly.

Are you unsure whether it’s right for you? Then start with the APK. After that, you’ll know where you stand, and you can decide for yourself whether mentoring is the right step.

Share this blog

Table of contents

Would you like more information?

Please feel free to contact us using the details below: